Vertical Accuracy Effect Verification for Satellite Imagery With Different GCPs

Abstract

This letter expands the block adjustment method by, respectively, adopting high-precision global positioning system (GPS) points, geoscience laser altimeter system (GLAS) data, and Shuttle Radar Topography Mission (SRTM)-digital elevation model (DEM) as vertical control data. Block adjustment experiments were conducted with these control data, with 388 ZY-3 satellite stereo image pairs across over 18600 km2 of land in Hubei province of China utilized as experimental images and 180 GPS points as checkpoints. The experimental results obtained show that, with the adoption of 23 GPS points as control points, the horizontal root-mean-square error (RMSE) and vertical RMSE of the ZY-3 image improved from 10.97 to 5.72 m and from 7.12 to 1.65 m, respectively. Furthermore, with the adoption of 326 GLAS data points as vertical control points, the vertical RMSE of the ZY-3 images of the flat terrain areas and mountain terrain areas improved to 1.69 and 3.62 m, respectively. Through block adjustment constrained by SRTM-DEM, the vertical RMSE of the ZY-3 images was 1.44 m for flat terrain areas and 3.05 m for mountain terrain areas, respectively. The vertical accuracy of the satellite images was significantly enhanced, especially on the flat terrain area, when GLAS and STRM-DEM were used for vertical control block adjustment, which is similar to the vertical accuracy of block adjustments adopting GPS points as control.