Vehicle Formulation Impacts Tolerability and Patient Preference: Comparison of Tretinoin Branded Lotion and Generic Cream

Abstract

Topical retinoids like tretinoin are a mainstay of acne treatment but associated cutaneous irritation and drying may lead to poor adherence. As vehicle optimization can improve patient preference and adherence, tretinoin 0.05% lotion (Altreno®) was formulated using polymeric emulsion technology for uniform delivery of micronized tretinoin and moisturizing/hydrating excipients. This study compared tolerability and participant preference of a branded tretinoin 0.05% lotion versus generic cream. In this single-center, double-blind, split-face study, 25 adult females with acne were randomized to apply lotion and cream to opposite cheeks once daily for 2 weeks. Investigator-assessed skin irritation and appearance, as well as participant ratings of the products and skin sensations, were evaluated immediately after first use and after 2 weeks. At week 2, there was significantly greater erythema, scaling, and dryness (122%–144%; P<0.01 each) and decreased skin softness, smoothness, radiance, and brightness (~40% difference; P<0.01 each) on the cream-treated versus lotion-treated side of the face. More participants agreed that the lotion was gentle, comfortable/soothing, spreadable, absorbent, not sticky, and left minimal residue versus cream (range: 72%–92% vs 8%–36%). Agreement scores on skin sensations (eg, soft, not dry, less dull) were similarly higher for lotion versus cream. Overall, ~70% of participants preferred to take home the lotion over the cream. After 2 weeks of once-daily use, tretinoin 0.05% lotion was associated with less irritation and superior skin appearance/ sensation versus generic 0.05% cream, with most participants preferring the lotion over cream. These results demonstrate the importance of a well-designed vehicle formulation on tolerability and patient preference. J Drugs Dermatol. 2022;21(8): 875-880. doi:10.36849/JDD.6945.