Variation of laparoscopic hernia repair in Scotland: A postcode lottery?

Abstract

Background and Purpose The laparoscopic approach is now recommended by NICE as the preferred technique for repair of bilateral and recurrent inguinal hernia and an accepted option for unilateral hernia. This study was set up to examine whether patients across Scotland had equal access to this method of treatment. Methods Information was collected on laparoscopic hernia repairs in adults at all acute general NHS hospitals in Scotland between the financial years 1997/8 and 2007/8. Private hospitals were excluded due to lack of data. The data were derived from SMR01 data of inpatient and daycase discharges from non-paediatric general acute NHS hospitals in Scotland as collected by the Information Services Division (ISD) of NHS National Services Scotland. Findings Of 6821 repairs in 2007/8, only 890 (13.0%) were performed laparoscopically, a small increase from 294 (4.5%) in 1997/8. The highest incidence of laparoscopic hernia repair in 2007/8 was in NHS Lothian, where 435 (41.1%) of all repairs were performed using the laparoscopic technique. Excluding NHS Lothian, the number of laparoscopic hernia repairs in the rest of Scotland showed a much smaller rise, from 184 (3.3%) to 455 (7.9%). NHS Lothian, (which has 20% of the Scottish population) performed 54.5% of laparoscopic repairs in Scotland between 1997/8 and 2007/8. In the most recent year available, 2007/8, 63.1% of bilateral primary, 53.7% of bilateral recurrent and 26.8% of unilateral recurrent hernia operations in Lothian were laparoscopic. This compares to only 9.9%, 7.0% and 7.1%, respectively, for other Scottish hospitals. Conclusions Despite the fact that laparoscopic hernia repair has several proven advantages over open techniques, particularly in bilateral and recurrent hernias, activity remains at a low level in Scotland with the exception of NHS Lothian. In Scotland, laparoscopic techniques are not being used as recommended by NICE guidelines and there appears to be a “postcode lottery” in the provision of this method of treatment. Possible reasons are discussed and action plans are suggested.