Variation in susceptibility to insecticides and synergistic effect of enzyme inhibitors in Pakistani strains of Trogoderma granarium

Abstract

Trogoderma granarium is an important quarantine insect pest of economic importance worldwide. Insecticides are heavily used against this pest that can reduce its susceptibility levels, and if left unchecked, this could lead to misuse of insecticides. Here, the susceptibility of five field strains of T. granarium in comparison to a reference strain (Lab-TG) was determined against pirimiphos-methyl, permethrin and spinosad using dose-mortality bioassays. Based on lethal dose (LD50 and LD99) values, the Lab-TG strain was the most susceptible to all the insecticides in comparison to the field strains. In the case of field strains, LD50 values varied from: 17.68–31.97 mg/kg for pirimiphos-methyl, 20.50–42.47 mg/kg for permethrin, and 1.34–5.00 mg/kg for spinosad. Whereas LD99 values for pirimiphos-methyl, permethrin and spinosad of field strains varied from 409.07 to 730.24 mg/kg, 374.24–949.48 mg/kg, and 11.41–72.25 mg/kg, respectively. The resistance ratios (RR) at LD50 and LD99 levels were in the range of 13.71–24.78 and 39.33–70.21 fold for pirimiphos-methyl; 13.49–27.94 and 37.31–94.66 fold for permethrin; 2.35–8.77 and 3.37–21.31 fold for spinosad, respectively. Considering the overall results, spinosad proved to be the most toxic insecticide to the laboratory and field strains of T. granarium when compared with toxicity of pirimiphos-methyl or permethrin. Insecticidal bioassays implementing enzyme inhibitors revealed no effect on synergizing the toxicity of all the insecticides in the Lab-TG strain; however, enzyme inhibitors significantly synergized toxicity of pirimiphos-methyl in all the field strain suggesting the major involvement of metabolic mechanism associated with pirimiphos-methyl resistance. The study demonstrates variation in susceptibility to insecticides in T. granarium strains. The results might be helpful for monitoring future variation in susceptibility to insecticides in T. granarium and for setting field rates.