Variation in pathogenicity among isolates of Elsinoe phaseoli from Phaseolus species

Abstract

SummaryExpanding primary leaves of 11 cultivars of Phaseolus vulgaris, and one each of Phaseolus coccineus, Phaseolus lunatus and Vigna unguiculata were inoculated with 23 isolates of Elsinoe phaseoli from Phaseolus spp. and one from Vigna unguiculata. On the basis of the macroscopic and microscopic appearance of the lesions, symptoms were placed into five classes. Spore yields from the lesions in each class were used to classify the types of lesions as representing resistance or susceptibility to each isolate. There was a differential response of cultivars to isolates. According to the reaction of five cultivars of P. vulgaris to infection, isolates were placed in four pathogenicity groups.In addition to the differential reaction of cultivars, there was some evidence of host specificity among the isolates. Thus, P. lunatus was susceptible to most of the P. vulgaris isolates but resistant to the ones from P. coccineus. Vigna unguiculata was susceptible only to the V. unguiculata isolate and was resistant to all the isolates from Phaseolus spp. The isolate from V. unguiculata failed to infect any of the bean cultivars or the other Phaseolus spp. The need to select suitable isolates for challenging cultivars in a breeding programme is stressed.