Variation between hospital caesarean delivery rates when Robson's classification is considered: An observational study from a French perinatal network.

Thibaud Quibel,Jean Bouyer,Patrick Rozenberg,Camille Bouyer,Alireza Abdollah Shamshirsaz

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0251141

Abstract

WHO has recommended using Robson's Ten Group Classification System (TGCS) to monitor and analyze CD rates. Its failure to take some maternal and organizational factors into account, however, could limit the interpretation of CD rate comparisons, because it may contribute to variations in hospital CD rates. To study the contribution of maternal socioeconomic and clinical characteristics and hospital organizational factors to the variation in CD rates when using Robson's ten-group classification system for CD rate comparisons. This prospective, observational, population-based study included all deliveries at a gestational age > 24 weeks at the 10 hospitals of the French MYPA perinatal network in the Paris area. CD rates were calculated for each TGCS group in each hospital. Interhospital variations in these rates were investigated with hierarchical logistic regression models to quantify the variation explained by differences in patient and hospital characteristics when the TGCS is considered. Variations in CD rates between hospitals were estimated with median odds ratios (MOR) to express interhospital variance on the standard odds ratio scale. The percentage of variation explained by TGCS and maternal and hospital characteristics was also calculated. The global CD rate was 24.0% (interhospital range: 17-32%). CD rates within each TGCS group differed significantly between hospitals (P<0.001). CD was significantly associated with maternal age (>40 years), severe preeclampsia, and two organizational factors: hospital status (private maternities) and the deliveries per staff member per 24 hours. The MOR in the empty model was 1.27 and did not change after taking the TGCS into account. Adding maternal characteristics and hospital organizational factors lowered the MOR to 1.14 and reduced the variation between hospital CD rates by 70%. Maternal characteristics and hospital factors are needed to address variation in CD rates among the TGCS groups. Therefore, comparisons of these rates that do not consider these factors should be interpreted carefully.

Highlights

World Health Organization (WHO) has recommended using Robson’s Ten Group Classification System (TGCS) to monitor and analyze cesarean delivery (CD) rates
CD was significantly associated with maternal age (>40 years), severe preeclampsia, and two organizational factors: hospital status and the deliveries per staff member per 24 hours
We developed regression models to quantify the extent to which variations in CD rates between maternity units remained when TGCS was taken into account and how the consideration of women’s socioeconomic and clinical characteristics and hospital organization factors might modify this variation

Summary

Methods

This prospective, observational, population-based study included all deliveries at a gestational age > 24 weeks at the 10 hospitals of the French MYPA perinatal network in the Paris area. CD rates were calculated for each TGCS group in each hospital. This study used data from a population-based cohort of births which occurred between the first January 2014 and the 31st December 2014 in in the MYPA (Materniteen Yvelines et Perinatalite Active) perinatal network, which covers the district of Yvelines (west of Paris). This network, which manages around 18,000 deliveries per year, is composed of 10 hospitals (referred to as hospitals A to J), including one hospital (A) affiliated with a university (Universite Versailles-Saint Quentin). The number of deliveries/years differed notably between hospitals: units A, B, and C each had more than 2,000 deliveries/year; units D, E, F, G, and H had between 1,000 and 2,000; and units I and J had fewer than 1,000

Results

Discussion

Conclusion