Variable niche breadth in benthic diatoms: Implications of ecological specialization and generalization for community structure

Abstract

The mechanisms that regulate the composition and structure of biological communities remain poorly understood. Diatom communities have traditionally been assumed to be a collection of r-selected, ecologically redundant generalist taxa with distributions constrained largely by dispersal limitation. Here, we challenge this notion by presenting a novel model that uses distributional data to estimate ecological specialization for groups of diatom taxa. We further develop this model to evaluate relationships among ecological specialization, taxonomic richness, and species’ abundance using field data collected from ancient Lake Matano and the broader Malili Lakes system (Sulawesi, Indonesia), as well as Mazinaw Lake (Ontario, Canada). We demonstrated that diatom niche breadth is highly variable both at the assemblage scale and among genera within assemblages. Ecologically-specialized genera exhibited higher taxonomic richness than their generalist counterparts, suggesting that ecological specialization serves to support the sympatric coexistence of multiple species by limiting competitive interactions among congeneric taxa. This assertion is further supported by species’ abundance patterns, which suggested that resources are evenly partitioned among taxa within specialist genera, while less-specialized genera are composed of taxa with either exceptionally high or exceptionally low abundances reflective of their relative success in competitive interactions with one another. Our findings indicate that the often-overlooked complement of rare taxa within diatom assemblages are in fact the entities that respond most sensitively to environmental conditions and are worthy of far greater consideration in environmental assessment and paleolimnological studies.