Variability in the quality of Pinus sylvestris needles and litter from sites with different soil characteristics: Lignin and phenylpropanoid signature

Abstract

Intact Pinus sylvestris needles and litter from the soil surface were sampled from several stands in SW England growing on soils with different chemical characteristics. The intrinsic chemical and biochemical characteristics of needle and litter samples were measured. The total concentration of lignin, measured by proximate analysis, and the chemical characteristics of the lignin-polymer in P. sylvestris needles and litter, varied between soil types. Lignin concentrations increased from 180 to 316 mg litter g −1 with increasing soil base saturation, although no similar trends in the concentration of lignin in needles were observed. The total concentration of phenylpropanoid moieties, released on CuO-oxidation, increased from 65.6 to 96.1 mg lignin g −1 in needles and 35.3–83.6 mg lignin g −1 in litters, which followed a trend of increasing soil base saturation under P. sylvestris stands. The concentration of NaOH-extractable moieties in needles increased from 1.79 to 2.35 μg sample g −1 with soil base saturation, as did the acid to aldehyde ratios of phenylpropanoid moieties in NaOH-extracts from litters. We conclude that the quality of lignin in needles and litter, as measured by its phenylpropanoid characteristics, varied significantly in P. sylvestris stands. In the light of the evidence from other studies that phenylpropanoid moieties have significantly different rates of microbial decomposition, this aspect of lignin quality should be considered when modelling the rate of litter mass loss and organic matter accumulation in forest soils. Furthermore, we have shown that by combining the CuO-oxidation technique with a NaOH-extraction procedure, phenylpropanoid signatures of a ‘bound’ and a relatively ‘labile’ lignin derived fraction in needles and litters can be more accurately monitored. A more extensive study is required to clarify the apparent relationships between the soil chemical characteristics beneath stands and the quality of lignin in plant materials.