Validity Study Comparing Polar Ignite’s® Estimated VO2max to Traditional Cardiopulmonary Exercise Testing in Normal Cardiac Anatomy & Fontan Pediatric Patients

Abstract

Cardiorespiratory fitness as represented by maximum oxygen uptake, VO2max, is considered the best indicator for overall cardiovascular health. Fitness technology such as wrist worn devices, now allows for an easy method to monitor an individual’s VO2max. This study sought to compare the estimated VO2max measurements from the Polar Ignite (Polar Electro Oy, Kempele, Finland) fitness watch (Polar Ignite) against the gold standard, cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPET) in normal cardiac anatomy and Fontan pediatric patients. This single-center, prospective study enrolled patients with normal cardiac anatomy and single ventricle patients with Fontan palliation (Fontan) between 13-21 years. The Polar Ignite was fastened on the patient’s right or left wrist while supine and estimated VO2max was generated based on a non-exercise test (Polar Fitness Test). A maximal voluntary CPET using the standard Bruce Treadmill Protocol was then completed. Measurements from the two tests were compared using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), Pearson correlation coefficient and Bland-Altman method. Forty-seven patients were enrolled, including n=36 (77%) normal cardiac patients and n=11 (23%) Fontan patients. The majority of participants were white (n=41, 87%) and female (n=36, 66%). Patients were 15.3±1.9 years old, weighed 65.7±16.6 kg, and were 168.0±10.4 cm tall on average. The mean estimated Polar Ignite VO2max and peak CPET VO2 was 43.9±6.1 ml/kg/min vs 37.7±8.2 ml/kg/min, respectively in the normal cardiac group, and 42.6±3.9 ml/kg/min vs 22.6±5.6 ml/kg/min, respectively in the Fontan group. We found poor validity (ICC=0.21) and a weak correlation (r=0.31, p=0.07) between VO2max measured by the Polar Ignite and CPET in the normal cardiac group and poor validity (ICC=0.08) and strong correlation (r=0.84, p=0.001) in the Fontan group. In Bland-Altman analyses, the mean bias between VO2max as measured by the Polar Ignite and CPET was 6.85 ml/kg/min among the normal cardiac group and 20.05 ml/kg/min among the Fontan group. The Polar Ignite overestimated VO2max compared to CPET in both the normal cardiac and Fontan groups and cannot replace formal testing.