Validation of the Use of Otoliths to Estimate Age and Growth of Larval Lake Whitefish, Coregonus clupeaformis

Abstract

Understanding drivers of recruitment variation in fish populations requires research conducted on early life stages. Examination of fish otoliths provides useful information for estimating hatching dates, growth, and survival rates of larvae and for investigating the relationship between early life stage phenology and variation in environmental factors such as climate and food availability. In the Laurentian (i.e., North American) Great Lakes, significant reductions in the number of young (ages 1–4 years) lake whitefish (Coregonus clupeaformis) recruiting into the population and commercial fishery have raised questions about factors affecting growth and survival of the larval life stage. Here, we investigate the utility of using otoliths to estimate the age and growth of larval lake whitefish. We raised offspring of wild-caught parents from Lake Simcoe (Ontario, Canada) in a hatchery environment and analyzed otoliths of these known age fish for 75 days posthatch. We further examined otoliths of wild-sampled larvae and age 0 lake whitefish from Lake Huron. We found a strong linear relationship between known age and number of postcheck increments on the otolith and between growth of the otolith and fish length. Increments formed at nearly 1 (0.9) per day beginning at day 20 after hatch. Check and subsequent increment formation was associated with disappearance of the yolk sac. Wild fish had more prominent checkmarks and grew slower than hatchery fish. Thus, otolith analysis represents a promising tool to examine dynamics of early life stages of lake whitefish, although further research is required on the effects of environmental conditions on otolith microstructure.