Validation of Administrative Codes for Identification of Staphylococcus aureus Infections Among Electronic Health Data

Abstract

Background: Epidemiological studies have utilized administrative discharge diagnosis codes to identify methicillin-resistant and methicillin-sensitive Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA and MSSA) infections and trends, despite debate regarding the accuracy of utilizing codes for this purpose. We assessed the sensitivity and positive predictive value (PPV) of MRSA- and MSSA-specific diagnosis codes, trends, characteristics, and outcomes of S. aureus hospitalizations by method of identification. Methods: Clinical micro biology results and discharge data from geographically diverse US hospitals participating in the Premier Healthcare Database from 2012–2017 were used to identify monthly rates of MRSA and MSSA. Positive MRSA or MSSA clinical cultures and/or a MRSA- or MSSA-specific International Classification of Diseases, Ninth/Tenth Revision, Clinical Modification (ICD-9/10 CM) diagnosis codes from adult inpatients (aged ≥18 years) were included as S. aureus hospitalizations. Septicemia was defined as a positive blood culture or a MRSA or MSSA septicemia code. Sensitivity and PPV for codes were calculated for hospitalizations where admission status was not listed as transfer; true infection was considered a positive clinical culture. Negative binominal regression models measured trends in rates of MRSA and MSSA per 1,000 hospital discharges. Results: We identified 168,634 MRSA and 148,776 MSSA hospitalizations in 256 hospitals; 17% of MRSA and 21% of MSSA were septicemia. Less than half of all S. aureus hospitalizations (49% MRSA, 46% MSSA) and S. aureus septicemia hospitalizations (37% MRSA, 38% MSSA) had both a positive culture and diagnosis code (Fig. 1). Sensitivity of MRSA codes in identifying positive cultures was 61% overall and 56% for septicemia, PPV was 62% overall and 53% for septicemia. MSSA codes had a sensitivity of 49% in identifying MSSA cultures and 52% for MSSA septicemia; PPV was 69% overall and 62% for septicemia. Despite low sensitivity, MRSA trends are similar for cultures and codes, and MSSA trends are divergent (Fig. 2). For hospitalizations with septicemia, mortality was highest among those with a blood culture only (31.3%) compared to hospitalizations with both a septicemia code and blood culture (16.6%), and septicemia code only (14.7%). Conclusions: ICD diagnosis code sensitivity and PPV for identifying infections were consistently poor in recent years. Less than half of hospitalizations have concordant microbiology laboratory results and diagnosis codes. Rates and trend estimates for MSSA differ by method of identification. Using diagnosis codes to identify S. aureus infections may not be appropriate for descriptive epidemiology or assessing trends due to significant misclassification.Funding: NoneDisclosures: Scott Fridkin reports that his spouse receives consulting fees from the vaccine industry.