Abstract
AimTo assess the usefulness of a short postal questionnaire as a method of follow-up in incisional hernia repair. Patients and methodAll consecutive patients (n=285) undergoing open mesh repair of incisional hernia using an onlay technique between 1998 and 2003 received a six-item self-administered questionnaire complemented with ideograms. Non-responders received two successive new questionnaires and a telephone call. All patients’ operation forms were reviewed. Patients with no objections to physical examination were contacted by phone for an appointment. The Fisher's exact test or the chi-square (χ2) tests were used to compare categorical variables between clinical visits and response to questionnaire. Agreement between response to the questionnaire and data on the operation forms was measured with the Cohen's kappa index and the Fleiss kappa index. The predictive values of the questionnaire were calculated. Results215 patients returned questionnaires after three reminders, allowing us to reach 75.4% of the study cohort, which in turn increased to 94% after the telephone call. A total of 168 (78.2%) patients were willing to come for a physical examination. Finally 62 (36.9%) patients were examined. The overall agreement between response to the questionnaire and data on the operation forms was poor (Cohen's kappa coefficient = 0.065 and Fleiss kappa coefficient = 0.170). ConclusionsA postal questionnaire can be effective to gather information. However, the usefulness of this information in the follow-up was low due to the small percentage of patients examined and difficulties in comprehension despite making the questionnaire short and illustrated by ideograms.
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have