Using climate change scenarios to evaluate future effectiveness of potential wetlands in mitigating high flows in a Midwestern U.S. watershed

Abstract

The Midwestern United States have seen increased flooding and droughts from climate change, urban development, deforestation, and wetlands removal. Adding new wetlands in the landscape have been proposed as a conservation strategy, especially in tile-drained agricultural watersheds, to increase upland storage of runoff and reduce peak flows. The goal of this study was to evaluate the long-term performance of a set of potential wetlands identified in the Eagle Creek Watershed in central Indiana, U.S., to reduce a range of high flows estimated from future climate scenarios. The Soil and Water Assessment Tool model was forced with bias-corrected climate projections from the North American Regional Climate Change Assessment Program to evaluate the impacts of climate change on watershed hydrology and peak flows. The ensemble of climate projections predicted both increase and decrease in magnitudes of the 5% exceedance flow from the past (1971–2000) to the future (2041–2070) time period. However, the model predicted that if the potential wetlands existed in these time periods then the magnitude of the 5% exceedance flow would be reduced by approximately 0.5–1.5m3/s across all climate projections and for both the past and future periods. These identified potential wetlands, which occupied only approximately 1.5% of the watershed area but received runoff from approximately 29% of the watershed area, were also found to reduce peak flows by up to 20–60m3/s (i.e., 15–20% of the reference peak flows for a watershed without these wetlands). The wetlands were also found to decrease the frequency of high peak flows. Wetlands proved to be a robust solution for peak flow reduction, producing consistent reductions from the past to future time periods and across all climate projections. The methodology used in this study to incorporate climate change into hydrologic models to evaluate conservation practices could also be applied to other watersheds and other conservation practices for better long-term watershed management decisions.