Using a novel strategy to identify the clustered regions of associations between short-term exposure to temperature and mortality and evaluate the inequality of heat- and cold-attributable burdens: A case study in the Sichuan Basin, China

Abstract

BackgroundFew studies have focused on the spatially clustered regions in the association between short-term exposure to temperature and mortality, which is important for identifying high-susceptibility population and enhancing the prevention of high/low temperatures. Previous studies have explored the association inequality, but no study has evaluated the inequalities of temperature-attributable burdens, which may be more meaningful for reducing temperature-related regional inequality. MethodsTaking the Sichuan Basin (SCB), an economically imbalanced area with high humidity and four distinctive seasons, as an example, we used a novel multi-stage strategy to investigate the two issues. First, distributed lag nonlinear models were independently constructed to obtain the county-level associations between daily temperature and cardiorespiratory mortality. Then, an estimation-error-based spatial scan statistic was used to detect the association-clustered regions. Third, multivariate meta-regression incorporating the identified clustered regions and socioeconomic and natural factors was used to obtain stable county-specific associations, based on which the heat- and cold-attributable deaths were mapped and their inequalities were evaluated using concentration indices and Lorenz curves. ResultsOn average, a U-shaped temperature-mortality association was examined. A significantly association-clustered region was detected (P = 0.017), in which heat and cold temperatures presented significantly stronger associations than those in the non-clustered region, particularly for heat temperatures. The cold-attributable deaths (3.5%) were substantially more than the heat-attributable deaths (0.5%). Both presented severe inequalities over counties. Significant temperature-attributable inequalities were also found over per-capital public budget, urbanization rate, employment rate and per-capital GDP. The directions of inequalities over GDP and urbanization rate were opposite between heat and cold temperatures. ConclusionsOur analysis provided the first evidence about the clustering of temperature-mortality associations and the inequality of cold- and heat-attributable burdens. Significantly association-clustered regions and heavy temperature-attributable inequalities were found in the SCB. Rural people bore heavier cold-attributable but less heat-attributable mortality risk than urban people, suggesting that different policies should be designed to reduce the temperature-attributable inequalities for heat and cold temperatures and different regions. This novel strategy can provide an interesting new perspective in the association between environmental exposure and human health.