Use of Co2 Laser versus conventional microlaryngeal surgery in treatment of vocal fold benign lesions

Abstract

Abstract Background Benign superficial lesions of vocal fold (nodule, polyp, cyst and Reinke's edema) arise from the epithelium and the lamina propria. Vocal abuse and misuse presumably lead to excessive mechanical stress and trauma in the membranous portion of vocal fold, resulting in wound formation. Wound healing leads to remodeling of the superficial layer of the lamina propria. This tissue remodeling leads to formation of benign vocal fold lesions. These lesions are classically treated by conventional microsurgery and recently by CO2 laser. The use of the CO2 laser for the surgical treatment of Minor Associated Pathological Lesions (MAPL's) is still controversial. Some preferred cold instruments, whereas others appreciate CO2 laser as a novel alternative to conventional microsurgery for benign vocal fold lesions. To summarize the reviewed literature the issue of CO2 laser versus cold instruments is still controversial and the stage is open for more studies. Aim The aim of this study is to investigate the effect of Co2 Laser versus cold instruments in the treatment of benign lesions of the vocal folds regarding voice outcome & vocal fold function. Methodology A meta-analysis study is done to assess the use of Co2 Laser versus conventional microlaryngeal surgery in treatment of vocal fold benign lesions. Results This study does not reveal any detectable differences in clinical outcomes in patients with nodules, polyps and cysts who underwent excision via CO2 laser or cold instruments. Conclusion There is no sufficient evidence to determine if conventional surgery or CO2 assisted surgery is better.