Use of characteristic functions derived from proficiency testing data to evaluate measurement uncertainties

Abstract

Interlaboratory comparisons show that reproducibility standard deviations are dependent on the concentration of the analyte. Many attempts have been made to model this. In this paper, ‘characteristic’ functions are used for modelling the concentration dependence of the reproducibility standard deviations based on data from proficiency tests for water analysis. The characteristics of the resulting functions can be used for the estimation of measurement uncertainties at different concentration levels. These functions are especially useful to determine the concentration levels below which absolute uncertainties tend to be constant and above which the relative uncertainties are more constant. By comparing the characteristic functions of different analytical procedures for the determination of the same analyte, the performance of these procedures under routine application can be compared. Finally, these functions may be used to get an indication on the average quality of analytical result in a specific field to be used by regulators in order to formulate requirements in the legislation that are in accordance with current measurement quality.