Use of ANOVA to Estimate Inter- and Intra-reader Variability for a Group of Readers in Thorough QT/QTc Studies

Abstract

The E14 guidelines of the International Conference on Harmonization require that all new drugs that have systemic bioavailability be subjected to a thorough QT/QTc study to look for possible effects on cardiac repolarization. Recent publications have discussed various aspects of thorough QTc studies. The thorough QTc study is designed to detect a mean drug-induced QTc prolongation of >5 ms with an upper bound of the 95% one-sided confidence limits of >10 ms. The E14 guideline has spelled out the procedures to be followed in a thorough QT/QTc study, including choice of subjects, methods of electrocardiogram (ECG) acquisition, details of ECG analysis, and statistical analysis of the study data. Since the measurement of the QT interval is a relatively subjective assessment, the ECGs must be analyzed in a central ECG laboratory by "a few skilled readers." In order to maintain quality in ECG interpretation, the E14 guidelines have two requirements. First, as a measure of the assay sensitivity, the study must include an active control known to prolong the QTc interval. Second, a certain percentage of ECGs must be subjected to an inter- and intra-reader variability analysis; these data are submitted to the regulatory authorities along with the study results.