Upper limit of mineral-associated organic carbon in temperate and sub-tropical soils: How far is it?

Abstract

Soil organic carbon (SOC) is the main terrestrial C pool and is roughly divided into stable mineral-associated organic carbon (MAOC) and particulate organic matter fractions. However, the sequestration capacity of MAOC remains unquantified. Currently, soils are considered to have a limited capacity to accumulate MAOC, primarily due to the presence of fine fractions, i.e. silt and clay particles. It is unlikely that saturation will occur in all soils due to land use, thus necessitating the investigation of whether soils are from different latitudes and whether SOC affects the saturation of the silt and clay fraction comprising MAOC. We selected 71 soil samples that were physically fractionated from a Mexican inventory of vegetation with a wide range of SOC (4–186 g kg−1 soil) and clay (126–777 g kg−1 soil) contents. Soils were grouped into non-volcanic soils and allophanic Andosols. In the first group, we found a positive and highly significant linear relationship between SOC and MAOC contents, but no upper limit was detected. We found a common slope of 0.86 (R2 = 0.97, p < 0.01), i.e. 86% of the SOC was contained in MAOC irrespective of soil types and management, a value very similar to that in other studies. Conversely, for allophanic Andosols, which had SOC content twice that of non-volcanic soils, a second-order polynomial function (R2 = 0.98, p < 0.01) was established, the upper limit of which exceeded 186 g SOC kg−1 for an MAOC of 134 g kg−1. This was also supported by an increasing polynomial function of particulate organic carbon as the SOC increased. In both types of soils, maximum MAOCs were found between 700 and 800 g kg−1 of silt and clay in medium-textured soils. The amount of silt and clay particles was limited by SOC accumulation in the silt fraction as clay became saturated. These results are influenced by the mass proportion of silt and clay that follows a unique pattern in allophanic Andosols and non-volcanic soils. An investigation of a comprehensive database comprising 21,315 soil profiles sampled 0–30 cm across Mexico showed that most soils are below 186 g SOC kg−1 the bending point above which the upper limit does exist.