Upholding Maritime Migrants’ Rights at the Borders of Europe – J.A. and Others v. Italy

Abstract

Abstract Countless people have left the African continent seeking to reach European shores via the central Mediterranean Sea route, despite persistent efforts by Italian and EU authorities to counter migratory activities. International and regional human rights judicial bodies have provided some responses to the abuses faced by maritime migrants both at sea and on land throughout the years. In this case note, I analyze the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights in J.A. and Others v. Italy concerning the detention of maritime migrants in the Lampedusa hotspot center. To this end, I first illustrate the facts of the case. Second, I assess each claim made by the applicants in relation to the human rights abuses they suffered: inhuman and degrading treatment, arbitrary detention, and collective expulsion of aliens. I conclude that the judgment constitutes an important development in the Court’s case law upholding maritime migrants’ rights, albeit characterized by a few shortcomings. I also argue that the Court’s position as a human rights judicial body needs to be further strengthened in the future.