‘Unsuitable’ environments: a qualitative study of US college youth learning online while sheltering-in-place in spring 2020

Abstract

ABSTRACT In late April 2020, we asked young adult college students to describe how they were impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic. This study analyzes data from the 370 students (52.3% of all students surveyed) who chose to describe their experiences with online learning in their response. Many students, and especially students from marginalized backgrounds (e.g. women and transgender and gender diverse, LGBTQ+, low-socioeconomic position), reported diverse hardships that were induced and/or exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic that affected their learning. Most of these adverse experiences were tied to students’ shelter-in-place and remote learning conditions, which we frame as ‘unsuitable environments’, that limited students from engaging academically in the same ways they might have on campus. We situate these unsuitable environments within an intersectional social-ecological model to demonstrate how students’ transformed nested environments impact academic engagement and have implications for equity within institutions of higher education – an ecological disruption whose impacts remain important to evaluate in future research on online learning in higher education.