Unsuccessful trial of labor in women with and without previous cesarean delivery

Abstract

Objective. To compare maternal and neonatal outcomes after unsuccessful labor in women with and those without prior cesarean delivery.Methods. This was a retrospective cohort study of all women in labor delivered by cesarean section (CS) from November 2004 through December 2006. The study population was dichotomized by previous CS and compared for various maternal and neonatal outcomes. Student t-test, χ2 and Fisher exact tests were used for analysis.Results. There was a significantly higher rate of symptomatic uterine rupture [3/100 (3%) vs. 0/449 (0%), p = 0.006], asymptomatic uterine scar dehiscence [6/100 (6%) vs. 0/449 (0%), p = 0.0001], and bladder injury [2/100 (2%) vs. 0/100 (0%), p = 0.001], among women with prior cesarean delivery compared to those without. The rate of respiratory distress syndrome [(6/100) (6%) vs. 10/449 (2.2%), p = 0.05] and meconium aspiration [4/100 (4%) vs. 2/449 (0.4%), p = 0.01] was also significantly higher among neonates of women with prior cesarean delivery. However, the rate of endomyometritis [3/100 (3%) vs. 50/449 (11.1%), p = 0.009] and febrile morbidity [17/100 (17%) vs. 144/449 (32.1%), p = 0.003] was significantly lower among women with prior cesarean delivery compared to those without prior cesarean birth.Conclusions. Compared to laboring women without previous cesarean delivery, women with previous cesarean delivery have increased maternal and neonatal morbidity. Febrile morbidity was, however, lower among women with previous cesarean delivery. These differential findings should further inform our perinatal counseling of women contemplating trial of labor after a previous cesarean delivery.