Unravelling interacting barriers and facilitators to adherence and delivery of exercise-based care in the treatment of Subacromial Pain Syndrome – an exploratory qualitative study

Abstract

Purpose Subacromial Pain Syndrome (SAPS) is a common persistent pain condition. Exercise-based care is first-line recommendation, but an insufficient exercise dose hampers effectiveness. This study explores individual and contextual barriers and facilitators for delivery of and adherence to exercise-based care in people with SAPS. Materials and Methods Participants in this exploratory qualitative study were involved in the management of SAPS in Denmark. Triangular interviews and analyses were conducted within 3 themes (delivery of recommended services, adherence to recommendations, and frames of the clinical pathways) using the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) and the Behavioural Change Wheel model (BCW) to map barriers and facilitators into the Capability, Opportunity, Motivation and Behaviour (COM-B) model. Results From interviews with 10 persons with SAPS and 37 healthcare practitioners and double-deductive analyses, 30 subjects of target behaviour within 13 TDF domains emerged across perspectives and COM-B components. Central barriers to delivery and adherence were inconsistencies in diagnostic terminology, cross-professional disagreements, beliefs, and expectations towards pathway services. Conclusion We identified interrelated individual and contextual barriers to delivery and adherence across all aspects of the BCW, underpinning the complexity of the subject. Findings support that effectiveness of exercise-based care is linked to contextual barriers to delivery and adherence.