Unlocking equity: assessing for gaps in cardiovascular guidelines for pregnant women

Abstract

Abstract Introduction Cardiovascular disease is the primary contributor to pregnancy-related fatalities in the United States, displaying a gradual rise over the years. Pregnancy introduces unique physiological changes that can impact pre-existing cardiovascular conditions and trigger new complications. Considerable inequalities in pregnancy-related mortality built on race and ethnicity are unmistakable, with the highest rates observed in black non-Hispanic women. Purpose This study aims to evaluate current gaps in racial/ethnic minority participation in randomized control trials (RCTs) cited in major cardiology guidelines. Methods Citations in the 2018 ESC Guidelines for the Management of Cardiovascular Diseases During Pregnancy were evaluated for RCTs. The American Heart Association and American College of Cardiology guidelines were also examined. Manuscripts and supplementary data were examined for participant-level racial or ethnic data, including age, race, and ethnicity. Results Thirteen RCTs, representing 20,665 participants, spanning the period from 2002 to 2017, were reviewed. European guidelines referenced thirteen of the RCTS, while American guidelines referenced two RCTs. The average age of participants was 31 years old. Most of the trials were conducted in Europe (46%). Forty-six percent of RCTs reported race/ethnicity breakdowns, with pooled participation showing a majority of non-Hispanic white participants (76.7%), with limited representation from other racial groups (table). Eight trials focused on hypertension, two on venous thromboembolism, and one on heart failure. Conclusion Pregnant women are frequently excluded from RCTs due to concerns about potential harm to the developing fetus. Consequently, current guidelines lack robust RCTs tailored to pregnant women with various cardiovascular diseases. The underrepresentation of ethnic minorities in cardiovascular disease trials contributes to a scarcity of evidence-based recommendations for managing these conditions during pregnancy and postpartum. Future clinical practice guidelines should advocate for a more personalized and evidence-based approach to managing cardiovascular diseases in pregnancy.