Unilateral cleft nose deformities at adulthood

Abstract

Secondary rhinoplasty is a challenging procedure, requiring a precise preoperative diagnosis of nasal deformities before correcting them. As there is currently no accepted outcome measurement tool available to assess unilateral cleft lip and palate (UCLP) nose sequelae before secondary rhinoplasty. The goal of this retrospective study is to identify the nose deformities and rate them in an evaluation scale that allows collecting and analyzing cleft nose data. Our retrospective cohort is composed of 29 patients with UCLP, who underwent secondary rhinoplasty between 2010 and 2021 in a cleft center, with a mean age of 23years old. Evaluation of deformities is made from preoperative two-dimensional photography. The assessment photographic tool is a custom-designed scale of 16 items. A binary scoring system is used by two experts to assess nasolabial deformities. The most encountered sequelaes are the alar foot displacement (93%), the enlarged tip (90%) and the nostril horizontalization (86%). The inter-examiner ICC for total rating was calculated at 0.911 and indicated a strong level of reliability that was highly significant (P<0.05). The simplicity, reliability and reproducibility of the proposed assessment system could be interesting for clinicians, in order to diagnose the nasal deformities before surgery, but also to assess postoperative success of a secondary rhinoplasty and thus to compare several surgical techniques.