Understanding the relationship between maternity care providers and middle-class Chinese migrant women in the Netherlands: A qualitative study

Abstract

ObjectiveThis study aims to provide insights into the formation and the quality of the maternity care provider-woman relationship between midwives, maternity care assistants and middle-class Chinese migrant women in the Netherlands. Designonline in-depth interviews addressing interpersonal trust, women's autonomy in shared decision making and culturally sensitive care Participants46 middle-class Chinese migrant women, 13 midwives and 12 maternity care assistants in the Netherlands FindingsMidwives and maternity care assistants reported challenges interpreting the needs of middle-class Chinese migrant women in care practices while Chinese migrant women experienced receiving insufficient emotional support. Midwives and maternity care assistant tended to attribute women's different preferences for care to culture which reinforced difficulties of addressing women's needs. Middle-class Chinese migrant women experienced a lack of responsive care, feelings of being overlooked, being uncomfortable to express different opinions and challenges in developing autonomy in the shared decision-making process. ConclusionsA trusting relationship, effective communication with maternity care providers, and a culturally sensitive and safe environment could be beneficial for middle-class migrant mothers. Chinese migrant women held ambivalent attitudes towards both traditional Chinese health beliefs and Dutch maternity care values. Each individual woman adopted the practice of the “doing the month” tradition to a different extent. This indicated the need for maternity care providers to recognize women's various needs for more responsive and individualized care, especially for first-time migrant mothers to negotiate their ways through the new healthcare system. Implications for practiceWe suggest a more proactive role for maternity care providers addressing the individual's subjectivity and preferences. Our findings are relevant and applicable for maternity care professionals conducting shared decision making with middle-class and highly educated migrant women living in Western contexts.