Understanding the phenomenological and intrinsic blazar sequence using a simple scaling model

Abstract

ABSTRACT The blazar sequence, including negative correlations between radiative luminosity Lrad and synchrotron peak frequency ν, and between Compton dominance Y and ν, is widely adopted as a phenomenological description of spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of blazars, although its underlying cause is hotly debated. In particular, these correlations turn positive after correcting Doppler boosting effect. In this work, we revisit the phenomenological and intrinsic blazar sequence with three samples, which are historical sample (SEDs are built with historical data), quasi-simultaneous sample (SEDs are built with quasi-simultaneous data) and Doppler factor corrected sample (a sample with available Doppler factors), selected from literature. We find that phenomenological blazar sequence holds in historical sample, but does not exist in quasi-simultaneous sample, and intrinsic correlation between Lrad and ν becomes positive in Doppler factor corrected sample. We also analyse if the blazar sequence still exists in subclasses of blazars, i.e. flat-spectrum radio quasars and BL Lacertae objects, with different values of Y. To interpret these correlations, we apply a simple scaling model, in which physical parameters of the dissipation region are connected to the location of the dissipation region. We find that the model generated results are highly sensitive to the chosen ranges and distributions of physical parameters. Therefore, we suggest that even though the simple scaling model can reproduce the blazar sequence under specific conditions that have been fine-tuned, such results may not have universal applicability. Further consideration of a more realistic emission model is expected.