Understanding earthquake location uncertainties using global sensitivity analysis framework

Abstract

SUMMARY Earthquake hypocentres are routinely obtained by a common inversion problem of P- and S-phase arrivals observed on a seismological network. Improving our understanding of the uncertainties associated with the hypocentral parameters is crucial for reliable seismological analysis, understanding of tectonic processes and seismic hazard assessment. However, current methods often overlook uncertainties in velocity models and variable trade-offs during inversion. Here, we propose to unravel the effects of the main sources of uncertainty in the location process using techniques derived from the Global Sensitivity Analysis (GSA) framework. These techniques provide a quantification of the effects of selected variables on the variance of the earthquake location using an iterative model that challenges the inversion scheme. Specifically, we consider the main and combined effects of (1) variable network geometry, (2) the presence of errors in the analyst’s observations and (3) errors in velocity parameters from a 1-D velocity model. These multiple sources of uncertainty are described by a dozen of random variables in our model. Using a Monte Carlo sampling approach, we explore the model configurations and analyse the differences between the initial reference location and 100 000 resulting hypocentral locations. The GSA approach using Sobol's variance decomposition allows us to quantify the relative importance of our choice of variables. It highlights the critical importance of the velocity model approximation and provides a new objective and quantitative insight into understanding the sources of uncertainty in the inversion process.