Uncertainty-Based Validation Methodology and Experimental Analysis for External Control Room Human Performance Simulation: Application to Fire Probabilistic Risk Assessment of Nuclear Power Plants

Abstract

In probabilistic risk assessment (PRA) of nuclear power plants (NPPs), human reliability analysis (HRA) is conducted to identify potential human failure events that could contribute to risk scenarios and estimate human error probabilities. Lessons learned from the 2011 Fukushima Daiichi NPP accident underscored that for PRA, it is critical to model external control room (Ex-CR) human actions. The state-of-practice HRA methods, historically developed for the main control room HRA, are limited in capturing the unique nature of Ex-CR human actions, such as location dependence (in addition to the time dependence) of human actions and spatiotemporal interactions of human performance with the surrounding physical environments, for instance, hazard propagation. To advance the Ex-CR HRA in the context of the fire PRA for NPPs, the authors’ team developed a simulation-based fire crew performance model using an agent-based modeling (ABM) technique. The ABM fire crew simulation was coupled with a fire progression model through a spatiotemporal interface using a geographic information system. This paper focuses on the validation of the ABM simulation, which is the key requirement for the simulation-based Ex-CR human performance model to be utilized in PRA. The existing validation approach, initially developed for physical models in the fire PRA of NPPs, is extended for validation of the simulation-based Ex-CR human performance model. Model uncertainty is used as a measure of model validity, which facilitates the incorporation of the validation result into the PRA. The degree of the model uncertainty is characterized by a lognormal error model whose parameters are quantified based on a pairwise comparison between empirical data and model predictions. The proposed validation approach is demonstrated using a case study of the fire PRA of NPPs. This study makes two research contributions: (1) it is the first to validate the simulation-based Ex-CR human performance model against empirical human performance data and incorporate the validation result into the PRA of NPPs, and (2) this study, for the first time, conducts a controlled experimental test to collect empirical data for fire crew performance at NPPs.