Uncertainty assessment in socially responsible and Islamic stock markets in the short and long terms: an ARDL approach

Abstract

ABSTRACTThis study measures financial uncertainty for two classes of alternative financial assets (Dow Jones Islamic and Dow Jones Sustainability Indexes) and the conventional US stock market (Dow Jones Industrial Index) for the period of 1999–2017, using an asymmetric exponential GARCH model. Using an ARDL model, we propose an intertemporal dynamic analysis of uncertainty for Islamic and socially responsible stock markets. Our findings show that, first, conventional and ethical investments present high comparable levels of uncertainty for which the dynamics is time-varying. Second, uncertainty in the conventional US stock market has a significant and positive effect on the uncertainty in alternative stock markets. Thus, uncertainty characterizes conventional and ethical stock markets both in the short and long terms. In particular, while the short-term uncertainty of ethical markets might be associated with their characteristics, the long-term aspect of uncertainty for ethical funds is rather associated with the effect of the conventional stock market environment. Although these findings show mean-reversion and uncertainty spillovers from the alternative stock markets to the conventional US one, they suggest lack of safety and certainty for investments in ethic markets, which remain fragile and closely dependent on the conventional market.