Ultrasonographic Screening for Thyroid Cancer in Siblings of Patients with Apparently Sporadic Papillary Carcinoma

Abstract

Epidemiological studies have shown a higher risk of thyroid cancer among individuals who have a relative with papillary thyroid cancer (PTC) compared to those without a family history. This study evaluated the prevalence of thyroid cancer among subjects with only one first-degree relative (sibling) with PTC who had no palpable nodules, factors predictive of this malignancy, and the characteristics of tumors discovered during ultrasonographic screening. A total of 757 siblings of 447 patients with apparently sporadic PTC were examined. Nodules were palpable in 34 subjects (excluded). The 723 individuals without palpable abnormalities were submitted to thyroid ultrasonography and comprised the study group. The control group, consisting of 241 volunteers without a family history of thyroid cancer matched for gender and age to the study group, was also submitted to thyroid ultrasonography. All nodules ≥ 5 mm were examined by fine-needle aspiration cytology. Subjects with benign cytology were not submitted to surgery, whereas the subjects having malignant, suspicious for a malignancy, indeterminate, or inadequate cytology were referred for thyroidectomy. Ultrasonography detected nodules in 303 (41.9%) study subjects. PTC was observed in 5.94% of the 723 subjects studied (8% women and 3.75% men, p=0.017) and in 14.2% of the 303 subjects with nonpalpable nodular disease. In the control group, 80 (33.2%) of the volunteers had nodules. PTC was observed in 1.2% of them and in 3.8% of those with nodular disease. In addition, 7.17% of the 447 patients had siblings with PTC detected only by ultrasonography. Multicentricity of the tumor was the main predictor of the presence of malignancy in siblings of patients with PTC. Twenty-two subjects (3% of those screened) had tumors that were not intrathyroid microcarcinomas (whereas all three tumors detected in controls were intrathyroid microcarcinomas). Screening permitted an earlier diagnosis of the disease when compared to siblings with a spontaneous diagnosis. The present results favor ultrasonographic screening of first-degree relatives of patients with apparently sporadic multicentric PTC, especially among women.