Tunnel malpositions in anterior cruciate ligament risk cartilaginous changes and bucket-handle meniscal tear: Arthroscopic survey in both primary and revision surgery.

Abstract

There are not many chances to arthroscopically reassess how graft tunnel malpositions in primary anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) associate with intra-articular degeneration in revision ACLR. This study was aimed to evaluate whether radiographic tunnel position in primary ACLR affect cartilaginous changes and bucket-handle meniscus tears in revision ACLR. Thirty-five patients who underwent revision ACLR were recruited; their primary surgeries were single-bundle reconstructions. Tunnel positions were evaluated using the plain radiographs after primary surgery. The sagittal tunnel positions of the femur (FP) and tibia (TP) were determined on the lateral view. The articular cartilage was evaluated arthroscopically at primary and revision surgery using the International Cartilage Repair Society (ICRS) score. A progression of two grades was considered as cartilaginous changes. Meniscal tears were evaluated with an arthroscopic probe. Logistic regression analysis was conducted using the prevalence of cartilaginous changes or bucket-handle meniscus tears as the dependent variable; tunnel parameters were used as the independent variables. Seven patients (20.0%) had cartilaginous changes and nine patients (25.7%) had bucket-handle tears in the medial meniscus. In logistic regression analysis, %FP [odds ratio (OR): 1.212; P=0.007] and the cut-off of 60% in the FP (OR: 22.000; P=0.008) were correlated with cartilaginous changes. %TP (OR: 1.126; P=0.036) was correlated with the prevalence of bucket-handle meniscus tears. Anterior femoral tunnel malposition in the femur was associated with the cartilaginous changes, and posterior tibial tunnel malposition with the development of bucket-handle meniscus tears.