Try Nonmedical Approach First for Agitation

Abstract

SAN FRANCISCO — At least 80% of patients with dementia will experience agitation, according to Dr. Josepha A. Cheong of the University of Florida, Gainesville. The temptation, especially at in-patient facilities, is to go immediately to medical management for that agitation. But before reaching for the prescription pad, one should rule out medical causes for agitation, and try nonmedical management, which can be highly effective, Dr. Cheong told attendees at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Clinical Psychiatrists. In dealing with patients with dementia, Dr. Cheong said she asks herself how she would deal with the same patient if he or she were a 3− to 5-year-old child. “Has there ever been a time when you were raising [toddlers] that you wanted to just pull out that syringe of Haldol?” Dr. Cheong asked. “It would be nice, but that's not what we do. One, it's not socially acceptable. And two, it's not appropriate. “I really feel much the same way in treating agitation in dementia. A lot of times, there's a tendency to go straight to the meds. And there's nothing wrong with that if what's least restrictive has failed.” Urinary tract infections and dehydration constitute two common medical causes of agitation. “Even if they don't have a urinary tract infection, it's amazing how people will perk up if you just hydrate them a little bit,” Dr. Cheong said. Anticholinergics and over-the-counter medications can also result in agitation. Ditropan, which is used for urinary incontinence, is one of the biggest offenders, in Dr. Cheong's view. “I always tell patients and their families: ‘Look, it's better to be in Depends than to be demented because of Ditropan.’ This can make the difference between keeping someone at home and having them in a nursing home in restraints,” Dr. Cheong said. Drug interactions can also cause agitation. The combination of a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory agent and lithium is a frequent culprit. Once medical causes have been excluded, consider whether the patient has experienced a recent change in environment, which can often result in agitation. Has a beloved pet died recently? Has the care facility's routine changed? Is there a new nurse on the ward? Consider also whether the patient's agitation comes at a certain time of the day, or with certain activities. Shower time often precipitates agitation. One solution is simply not to insist that patients shower daily. Elderly patients often do fine showering or bathing just twice a week, and this has the extra benefit of preventing their skin from drying out. Another tip is for caregivers to enter the reality of the patient. People who work in geriatric units are used to seeing patients waiting every morning by the front door for the bus to take them to work. The patient is likely to become upset if he or she is told that he's been retired for 20 years. Instead, it might be better to say, “Why don't you come sit down and have some breakfast while you're waiting?” Overstimulation and understimulation should both be avoided. The change-of-shift chaos in many in-patient units can be highly disturbing to patients. This might be a good time to have patients away from the chaos in a quiet day room with soothing music. On the other hand, lack of activities and boredom can lead to restless behavior and attempts to escape. Studies show that simply adding a recreational therapist to a nursing-home setting can decrease the amount of agitation that patients experience. Keep the patients' choices simple. Three salad dressings and four choices of entrées at mealtimes may be confusing to the demented patient; it is much better to provide a single offering. Like toddlers, patients with dementia also do best with finger foods. Everyone has a need for attention, intimacy, and affection. The lack of that human connection can lead to agitation and impulsive sexual behavior. Soothing rituals such as massage or hair brushing can go a long way toward calming the agitated patient. Psychiatrists may have difficulty getting paid for nonmedical treatment of agitated patients, because Medicare may regard it as psychotherapy, and psychotherapy is not indicated for patients with dementia. Dr. Cheong's tip is to code the treatment as being for behavioral and psychotic symptoms of dementia.