Trouble de la personnalité borderline: état des connaissances et des représentations auprès de praticiens francophones en santé mentale

Abstract

ObjectivesPatients suffering from borderline personality disorder are very prevalent in various settings (emergency rooms, psychiatric and general hospitals, ambulatory consultations). However, it remains one of the most stigmatized and neglected mental health conditions, albeit being an area that is responsible for very interesting advances in psychotherapy. Today, the prognosis of patients with borderline personality disorder is rather favorable, provided that they follow a dedicated psychotherapy. Conceptions about this condition therefore deserve to be updated as it is sufficiently described in the literature that negative attitudes towards these patients diminish the quality of care they receive as well as their prognosis, and that these attitudes change with training. We decided to study the state of knowledge and attitudes towards borderline personality disorder in a group of French-speaking caregivers interested in these patients. MethodsBetween 2019 and 2020, at the start of training sessions in psychotherapeutic approaches to borderline personality disorder, we provided two questionnaires to 126 caregivers from various professional backgrounds (psychiatrists or child psychiatrists, psychologists, mental health nurses, social workers). The first consisted of 13 questions with 3 choice answers aimed at testing knowledge about borderline personality disorder and the second of 11 questions in the form of a Likert scale aimed at evaluating attitudes towards these patients (e.g. degree of comfort, involvement, hope, avoidance with these patients) adapted frome a questionnaire of Blake and colleagues. ResultsThe sample consisted of 126 caregivers (69 psychiatrists/pedopsychiatrists; 19 mental health nurses; 23 psychologists; 14 social workers). Fifty three of them (42.06 %) worked in an outpatient setting (either in a state facility or in private practice), 50 (39.68 %) worked in an inpatient psychiatric unit, 13 (10.32%) in both care systems, and 10 (7.94 %) worked in other facilities such as sheltered homes or workshops for persons with psychiatric disabilities. The average number of years in postgraduate training was 7.73 (SD=5.67; rank=0 to 31), and 35 (27.78%) had received at least one training course on borderline disorder in the past. The mean age of the sample was 37.89 (SD=10.08; rank=20 to 64) and there were 76 women (60.32%) and 50 men (39.68%). Concerning the first questionnaire (knowledge), the rate of correct responses among caregivers was relatively low (54%) considering that the vast majority of those assessed were caregivers already trained in mental health who were working with patients suffering from borderline personality disorder. The results showed a significant knowledge gap among professionals, in particular in the nursing profession, illustrating an ever more flagrant shortfall in formations in this sub-population. Concerning the second questionnaire (attitudes), the answers showed that attitudes of caregivers towards patients with borderline personality disorder were still tinged with fear and lack of confidence in taking charge of them. Thus, one participant out of five would have liked to avoid these patients, more than 12% of caregivers did not appreciate them, and 23% thought that they were manipulative. In addition, nearly half of the caregivers surveyed had low confidence in their ability to make a positive difference in the lives of borderline patients. However, there was a recognition of their distress as well as a demand for dedicated training. ConclusionsStigmas and ignorance persist around patients with borderline personality disorder. Current training courses do not allow caregivers who are on the front lines (in particular nurses) and who wish to be trained to acquire sufficient knowledge and tools necessary for the care of patients suffering from this disorder. This calls for an improvement in training as well as a reflection on the most appropriate approaches possible to the various target audiences.