Trophic niches determined from fatty acid profiles of sympatric coral reef mesopredators

Abstract

Previous research has identified similar trophic levels in a wide range of coral reef sharks and large teleost fishes but has been unable to resolve the extent of dietary overlap and resource sharing that lead to interpretation of functional roles and, hence, adequately describe interaction strengths in food webs. We used fatty acid (FA) profiles of muscle and plasma reflecting the diet of several mesopredators to better understand the trophic structure and functioning of Great Barrier Reef ecosystems. Multivariate analysis identified significant dietary overlap between 2 shark species (whitetip reef shark Triaenodon obesus and grey reef shark Carcharhinus amblyrhynchos), but whitetip reef sharks occupied a smaller niche area than grey reef sharks. We also found clear niche separation between sharks and teleost fishes (red throat emperor, coral trout, and grass emperor). All mesopredators sampled had high proportions of polyunsaturated FAs linking them to carnivory, but differences among species in trophic biomarker ratios suggest distinctive dietary sources. However, based on a degree of niche overlap of species sharing common diet, reef-dwelling teleost fishes such as coral trout also derive nutrients from pelagic environments. A faster analytical method to determine FA profiles, proven highly useful in tuna, was tested and deemed viable for muscle tissue of tropical teleost fishes and sharks, while questions remain for use of FA extraction of plasma in ecological studies. These results demonstrate that fine-scale inter-specific differences in diet exist between mesopredators in coral reef ecosystems. Our results raise important questions about the ecological influences of these species and energy flow among mesopredators in coral reef ecosystems.