Triple oxygen isotopes of cherts through time

Abstract

It has long been recognized that the stable oxygen isotope 18O/16O ratios of chemical sediments show a systematic decrease with increasing age. This continuous, 3.8 Ga long secular trend has been attributed to 80 °C hot early Earth oceans, a ~15‰ lower 18O/16O ratio of Archean seawater, or diagenetic obliteration of the original isotope signal. We demonstrate that high-precision triple oxygen isotope measurements including the rare third stable oxygen isotope 17O on silica rocks (cherts) can be used to shed light on this major problem in geochemistry. Our triple oxygen isotope data do not support 80 °C hot oceans in the Archean. The data also exclude that the 18O/16O of seawater was much lower in the Archean. Also, a simple freshwater-origin of cherts is not supported by the new data. We discuss the effects of diagenetic alteration on the triple oxygen isotope compositions of cherts and show that the Archean and Proterozoic cherts could have equilibrated with fluids with higher 18O/16O than today's oceans. For the Archean cherts, the high 18O/16O fluids required to explain the observations could reflect the composition of ambient seawater or of modified hydrothermal fluids. Oceans with higher 18O/16O ratio would be expected for an Archean “water world” without large continents. High 18O/16O fluids, however, could also have formed locally by reactions between seawater and the oceanic crust. Our study shows that high-precision triple oxygen isotope data provide new understandings of processes deep in time.