Trends in neurovascular complications of surgical management for carotid body and cervical paragangliomas: A fifty-year experience with 153 tumors

Abstract

Almost 75% of carotid body and cervical paragangliomas are adherent to or surround adjacent arteries and cranial nerves. Their resection can result in neurovascular injury, stroke, and excessive blood loss. To assess trends in neurovascular complications, we reviewed 153 carotid body and cervical paragangliomas that were surgically managed between 1935 and 1985. Results of the past 10 years were compared with two previous time periods: period I (1935 to 1965), when carotid artery reconstruction was uncommon at our institution, and period II (1966 to 1975), when methods of intraoperative electroencephalographic monitoring and carotid patch angioplasty were being developed. During the past 10 years (period III), surgical approach to these tumors has included intraoperative monitoring of cerebral blood flow, selective use of shunts, vein patch or graft reconstructions after extensive tumor resections, and mobilization of the parotid gland to facilitate adequate exposure of high tumors. Although tumor resection was attempted in 80% of patients in period I, surgical resection was complete in 98% during periods II and III. Three trends were observed: (1) The perioperative stroke rate has decreased dramatically from 23% in period 1 to 2.7% in period III (p = 0.007); (2) the perioperative mortality rate has been reduced from 6% in period I to no deaths in the past 10 years, but (3) the rate of postoperative cranial nerve dysfunction remains unchanged over 50 years (period I, 46%; period III, 40%). The median tumor size among patients with postoperative complications was significantly larger than those without complications (median size: 17 vs. 7 cm3, p = 0.004). Forty-eight percent of cranial nerve problems were permanent. Our experience clearly demonstrates that nearly all carotid body and cervical chemodectomas can be completely resected with minimal risk of stroke or death. Future refinement of surgical technique for these difficult tumors must focus on methods to minimize cranial nerve dysfunction.