Tree improvement increases the growth of white spruce (Picea glauca): Evidence from 15-year-old operational plantations in Alberta

Abstract

The timber producing forest land-base in Alberta, Canada, is decreasing due to the increase in allocation of land to other uses such as agriculture, infrastructure, energy development and conservation areas, while the demand for forest products continues to increase. Tree improvement, first implemented in Alberta in 1975, is one strategy used for increasing forest productivity to meet an increasing demand for fibre and forest products. To quantify the operational impact of tree improvement on white spruce productivity, we collected data from 15-year-old white spruce stands in Alberta: 11 stands planted with seedlings from improved (seed orchard) seedlots and seven stands planted with seedlings from wild (unimproved) seedlots. Eight plots (100 m2 circular plots) within each stand were randomly established for measurement (18 × 8 = 144 plots). Diameter at breast height (DBH), tree height, crown width, and branch diameter for each tree inside the plots were measured. Mixed effects models, with site and plot considered random, were used to evaluate the effect of tree improvement on the growth of white spruce. Basal area per ha of competitor species was used to develop a non-spatial competition index, and to compare the growth of improved and unimproved white spruce response to competition. Individual trees from improved stands showed 17% greater DBH and height compared to individual trees from unimproved stands. Individual trees of improved stands also had a greater height and smaller branch diameter for a given DBH than the trees grown in unimproved stands. Overall, tree improvement increased the site index of white spruce by 2 m while both improved and unimproved stands were similarly, and negatively, affected by competition. The application of tree improvement in white spruce resulted in an increase in growth rate, site index, and quality of timber, which will help offset the increasing demand for forest products.