Abstract

Transparency in internet regulation and governance: arguments and counter-arguments with some methodological reflections

Highlights

  • Our increasingly globalized society seems to be going through a deep crisis

  • Habermas’s (1984, 1987) contribution to sociological and politico-legal analysis is centred on argumentation theory. His approach to the study of arguments has always emphasised the ‘normative’ aspect (e.g. Habermas 1990), and he has always kept an eye on the wider, social contexts of argumentative events, in order to be able to complement any analysis of interactional, face-to-face argumentative exchanges with a focus on the wider, societal contexts. At this point of our argument we want to make clear that we do acknowledge the necessity of complementing the study of arguments with political analyses, but, following Habermas and those who built on his work, it is necessary to emphasise that any action, including those carried out in the ‘political’ sphere, must be able to stand to critical scrutiny, i.e. actors should be able to provide ‘reasons’ for them

  • After reviewing several influential contributions to the study of arguments as applied to practical/politico-legal and Public Policy and Administration (PPA) discourses, in the first part of the article we introduced our own take on the debate

Read more

Summary

Introduction

Our increasingly globalized society seems to be going through a deep crisis Such globalization is a complex phenomenon but it implies an inexorable transformation of our society, characterized by multiculturalism and diversity. Our aim is to highlight the importance of (re)evaluating a more comprehensive point of view, inclusive of intersectional and different knowledges/savours, which instead of excluding each other, it is enmeshed and intertwined in them. Through this methodological renewal, it becomes possible to understand the revolution imported by the Internet as well as our current information era. Before undertaking such reflections a discussion of the background disciplinary and methodological controversies surrounding our contribution will be tackled

Public Policy and Administration
Practical Wisdom?
Arguing in Favour of Argumentation
The Argumentative Approach
Beyond the Argumentative Turn
Argumentation Theory and PPA
Practical Reasoning and Argumentation
The Case of Transparency Regulation and Governance
Transparency and Internet in the new era of technology
10 Concluding Remarks
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call