Abstract

Several observational studies have found that the risk for breast cancer is significantly reduced in persons who engage in greater amounts of physical activity. Additional observational studies of breast cancer survivors indicate that greater physical activity before or after diagnosis associates with reduced disease-specific mortality. However, no large randomized controlled trials have examined the effect of structured exercise training on disease outcomes in breast cancer. Among the many hurdles in designing such trials lies the challenge of determining how a given regimen of exercise from efficacious preclinical studies can be extrapolated to an equivalent “dose” in humans to guide decisions around treatment regimen in early-phase studies. We argue that preclinical researchers in exercise oncology could better facilitate this endeavor by routinely measuring changes in exercise capacity in the subjects of their breast cancer models. VO2max, the maximal rate of whole-organism oxygen consumption during a progressive exercise test, is emphasized here because it has become a standard measure of cardiorespiratory fitness, is well-integrated in clinical settings, and scales allometrically among nonhuman animals in preclinical research and breast cancer patients/survivors in the clinic. We also conduct secondary analyses of existing whole-transcriptome datasets to highlight how greater uptake and delivery of oxygen during exercise may reverse the typically hypoxic microenvironment of breast tumors, which often associates with more aggressive disease and worse prognosis.

Highlights

  • Over the past 30 years, exercise therapists and other clinical investigators have conducted randomized controlled trials (RCTs) with cancer patients to examine the effect of structured exercise training on a variety of dependent variables

  • Spurred by emerging observational evidence that physically active women had a lower risk of developing breast cancer, clinical investigators soon began conducting RCTs to examine the effect of exercise on biomarkers that associate with breast cancer prognosis, doing so during and/or after initial adjuvant treatment [5, 6]

  • Informative, such studies have not led to any firm conclusions about the ability of structured exercise training to modulate disease outcomes in breast cancer patients

Read more

Summary

INTRODUCTION

Over the past 30 years, exercise therapists and other clinical investigators have conducted randomized controlled trials (RCTs) with cancer patients to examine the effect of structured exercise training on a variety of dependent variables. A recent meta-analysis of 48 such RCTs (the most prevalent being for breast cancer) found that VO2peak in cancer patients was significantly increased by exercise therapy in comparison to cancer patients in the control group [1], consistent with many other studies of unaffected individuals [19] Given that it serves as a robust indicator of exposure to routine aerobic/endurance activity [19], pre–post changes in measures of cardiorespiratory fitness like VO2max have been thought of as the “pharmacokinetic equivalent” for an exercise trial or as a manipulation check wherein the exercise regimen is shown to have done its job [8]. VO2max was not measured in either of these studies, we speculate that it would likely correlate with tissue hypoxia in an inverse manner

CONCLUSIONS
Findings
ETHICS STATEMENT
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call