Transformation is an alternative to normal skeletal muscle development

Abstract

The differentiation of skeletal muscle is characterized by cessation of proliferation and fusion of single myoblasts to form non-replicating multinucleate fibers (myotubes). If termination of proliferation is an obligate requirement for further differentiation, myoblasts defective in this stage of development should fail to fuse or exhibit any further characteristics of myotubes. Furthermore, myoblasts which have lost the ability to control and cease proliferation may represent a transformed, potentially tumorigenic population. Formation of the neoplastic state may therefore be viewed as an alternate path, antithetical to the normal differentiation of skeletal muscle. To test this hypothesis, we isolated 13 clones of non-fusing cells from the myogenic L 8 line of rat myoblasts. In contrast to the L 8 line, all of the non-fusing clones maintain their proliferative capacity, do not form myotubes, nor elevated creatine kinase activity nor increased myosin, but do develop into tumors when injected into athymic mice. L 8 cells do not produce tumors in these mice. Analysis of cell growth and serum requirements, plasminogen activator, hexose transport, adhesiveness, LETS protein and growth in soft agar, indicates that these non-fusing cells are transformed and clearly distinguished from the parent L 8 cells. Whereas the L 8 line maintains a near diploid complement of chromosomes, all non-fusing clones were polyploid. In addition, 12 of 13 non-fusing clones (but not the L 8 cells) express an endogenous type C virus. Although all clones defective in differentiation formed tumors, no single in vitro characteristic was found to be a constant index of this tumorigenic capacity. We conclude that cessation of proliferation is an obligate requirement for skeletal myogenesis, that transformation is an alternative to normal skeletal muscle development and that the phenotype of these transformed cells may be quite varied.