Transfer of potentially toxic elements from biosolid-treated soils to maize and wheat crops

Abstract

There is widespread concern about the risk of potentially toxic elements (PTE) soil and crops accumulate but most studies with biosolids have shown different and even contradictory results. Under field conditions we studied: (i) the accumulation of PTE by maize (Zea mays L.) and wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) from biosolid treated soils and (ii) the ability of total or EDTA extraction to represent the availability of PTE. We sampled plots from nine experiments with maize from controls and biosolid doses up to 45 t DM/ha and four experiments with wheat to biosolid doses up to 30 t DM/ha. The studies were carried out in the Northwest of Buenos Aires province, Argentina. Top soils and plants (shoot and grain) were sampled. Soils were digested with acids or extracted with EDTA. Shoots were digested with acids. Cadmium, chromium, copper, lead, nickel and zinc were determined by ICPES. Boron, cobalt, manganese and molybdenum in maize were also determined in two experiments. The concentrations of PTE in biosolid were below regulatory concentrations but its application increased some PTE concentration in the soil. Crop yields increased when biosolid were applied in high doses and most PTE concentrations were within normal values. Correlations between total manganese and EDTA extractable copper in soils and in maize, and total copper, lead and zinc in soils and in wheat were found. Application of biosolids increased some PTE concentration in soils, but there is no correlative increase in PTE concentration in maize and wheat shoot or grains. The PTE extraction using EDTA does not represent better PTE crop availability than the total extraction.