Transdentinal cytotoxicity of resin luting cements using the bovine and human dentin barrier

Abstract

Based upon ethical questions and because of the difficulty of obtaining intact human teeth, researchers have used bovine teeth to assess the physical and mechanical properties of different dental materials. However, data from transdentinal cytotoxicity tests showing that the bovine dentin barrier is similar to the human dentin barrier is lacking. The purpose of this in vitro study was to evaluate whether the bovine dentin barrier produces similar results to those obtained when the human dentin barrier is used to assess the transdentinal cytotoxicity of resin luting cements. The number and diameter of dentinal tubules present in the human dentin barrier and bovine dentin barrier were evaluated and assessed with a t test (α=.05). After inserting the standardized dentin barriers into artificial pulp chambers, murine dental papilla-derived cells (MDPC-23) were seeded on the pulpal surface of the specimens, and the luting cements were applied to their occlusal surfaces. Then, the following groups were established for both human and bovine dentin barriers: no treatment (negative control); Single Bond Universal; RelyX Luting 2; RelyX U200; and RelyX Ultimate. After 24 hours, the viability (alamarBlue) and morphology (scanning electron microscopy) of the cells were evaluated with a 2-way analysis of variance and the Tukey honest significance test (α=.05). Dentinal tubules with larger diameters were observed in bovine dentin (P<.05), but the number of tubules was similar (P>.05). A reduction in viability and notable changes in the morphology of MDPC-23 cells occurred in the Single Bond Universal and RelyX Luting 2 groups in comparison with the negative control (P<.05). The RelyX U200 and RelyX Ultimate groups were statistically similar to the negative control (P>.05). No difference was found in cytotoxicity when the same luting cement was applied on human or bovine dentin barriers (P>.05). For transdentinal cytotoxicity tests of resin luting cements, the bovine dentin barrier proved similar results to the human dentin barrier.