Trans in Arcadia: Transgender lives in the countryside and expanding Philo's ‘rural others’ beyond the cis

Abstract

This paper argues that Chris Philo's original 1992 call to recover the geographies of ‘rural others’, and the subsequent focus on marginalised lives that has emerged in rural studies in the three decades since, has yet to lead to a significant body of work on rural trans people. Whilst the straight white middle-aged male perspective dominating rural studies—Philo's ‘Mr Average’—has been interrogated on almost every other score, his likely cisgender identity has not. With the current prominence of the ‘gender-critical’ movement, and the recent decision by the UK government not to ban trans conversion therapy, transphobia in the UK is at fever pitch. Arguments against transgender rights typically claim that anti-trans beliefs are ‘common sense’ and held by most ‘average people’. UK polls indeed show that those most likely to be transphobic are male, over 50, and probably white—Philo's ‘Mr Average’ indeed. This suggests that transphobia is most rife in places where ‘Mr Average’ is concentrated, such as rural areas. So what happens when a trans person not only lives in the English countryside, but publicly transitions there? This paper tells the story of a woman named Valerie as seen through the eyes of the ‘Mr and Mrs Averages’ that otherwise populate her village community, using it both to critique the sweeping assumptions about ‘common sense’ that anti-trans activists rely on, and to demonstrate why rural studies, having explored marginalised lives for over 30 years, should now extend that curiosity and courtesy to trans people too.