Trade-off in healthy tissue sparing of FLASH and fractionation in stereotactic proton therapy of lung lesions with transmission beams.

Abstract

Besides a dose-rate threshold of 40-100Gy/s, the FLASH effect may require a dose>3.5-7Gy. Even in hypofractioned treatments, with all beams delivered in each fraction (ABEF), most healthy tissue is irradiated to a lower fraction dose. This can be circumvented by single-beam-per-fraction (SBPF) delivery, with a loss of healthy tissue sparing by fractionation. We investigated the trade-off between FLASH and loss of fractionation in SBPF stereotactic proton therapy of lung cancer and determined break-even FLASH-enhancement ratios (FERs). Treatment plans for 12 patients were generated. GTV delineations were available and a 5mm GTV-PTV margin was applied. Equiangular arrangements of 3, 5, 7, and 9 244MeV proton transmission beams were used. To facilitate SBPF, the number of fractions was equal to the number of beams. Iso-effective fractionation schedules with a single field uniform dose prescription were used: D95%,PTV=100%Dpres per beam. All plans were evaluated in terms of dose to lung and conformity of dose to target of FLASH-enhanced biologically equivalent dose (EQD2). Compared to ABEF, SBPF resulted in a median increase of EQD2mean to healthy lung of 56%, 58%, 55% and 54% in plans with 3, 5, 7 and 9 fractions respectively and of 236%, 78%, 50% and 41% in V100% EQD2, quantifying conformity. This can be compensated for by FERs of at least 1.28, 1.32, 1.30 and 1.23 respectively for EQD2mean and 1.29, 1.18, 1.28 and 1.15 for V100%,EQD2. A FLASH effect outweighing the loss of fractionation in SBPF may be achieved in stereotactic lung treatments. The trade-off with fractionation depends on the conditions under which the FLASH effect occurs. Better understanding of the underlying biology and the impact of delivery conditions is needed.