Toxicity of rare earth elements (REEs) to marine organisms: Using species sensitivity distributions to establish water quality guidelines for protecting marine life

Abstract

A lack of chronic rare earth element (REE) toxicity data for marine organisms has impeded the establishment of numerical REE water quality benchmarks (e.g., guidelines) to protect marine life and assess ecological risk. This study determined the chronic no (significant) effect concentrations (N(S)ECs) and median-effect concentrations (EC50s) of eight key REEs (yttrium (Y), lanthanum (La), cerium (Ce), praseodymium (Pr), neodymium (Nd), gadolinium (Gd), dysprosium (Dy) and lutetium (Lu)) for 30 coastal marine organisms (encompassing 22 phyla and five trophic levels from temperate and tropical habitats). Organisms with calcifying life stages were most vulnerable to REEs, which competitively inhibit calcium uptake. The most sensitive organism was a sea urchin, with N(S)ECs ranging from 0.64 μg/L for Y to 1.9 μg/L for La and Pr, and EC50s ranging from 4.3 μg/L for Y to 14.4 μg/L for Pr. Conversely, the least sensitive organism was a cyanobacterium, with N(S)ECs ranging from 121 μg/L for Y to 469 μg/L for Pr, and EC50s ranging from 889 μg/L for Y to 3000 μg/L for Pr. Median sensitivity varied 215-fold across all organisms. The two-fold difference in median toxicity (μmol/L EC50) among REEs (Y ∼ Gd > Lu ∼ Nd ∼ Dy ∼ Ce > La ∼ Pr) was attributed to offset differences in binding affinity (log K) to cell surface receptors and the percentage of free metal ion (REE3+) in the test waters. The toxicity (EC50) of the remaining REEs (samarium, europium, terbium, holmium, thulium and ytterbium) was predicted using a combination of physicochemical data and measured EC50s for the eight tested REEs, with good agreement between predicted and measured EC50s for selected organisms. Numerical REE water quality guidelines to protect marine life were established using species sensitivity distributions (e.g., for 95 % species protection, values ranged from 1.1 μg/L for Y to 3.0 μg/L for La, Pr or Lu).