Towards the understanding of fully-heavy tetraquark states from various models

Abstract

We use a color-magnetic interaction model (CMIM), a traditional constituent quark model (CQM) and a multiquark color flux-tube model (MCFTM) to systematically investigate the properties of the states $[Q_1Q_2][\bar{Q}_3\bar{Q}_4]$ ($Q=c,b$). The dynamical investigation indicates that the CMIM can not completely absorb QCD dynamical effects through the effective constituent quark mass and overestimates the color-magnetic interaction in the states under the assumption of the same spatial configurations. The Coulomb interaction plays a critical role in the dynamical model calculations on the heavy hadrons, which induces the fact that none of bound states $[Q_1Q_2][\bar{Q}_3\bar{Q}_4]$ can be found in the dynamical models. The color configuration $\left[[Q_1Q_2]_{\mathbf{6}_c}[\bar{Q}_3\bar{Q}_4]_{\bar{\mathbf{6}}_c}\right]_{\mathbf{1}}$ should be taken seriously in the ground states due to the strong Coulomb attraction between the $[Q_1Q_2]_{\mathbf{6}_c}$ and $[\bar{Q}_3\bar{Q}_4]_{\bar{\mathbf{6}}_c}$. The color configuration $\left[[Q_1Q_2]_{\bar{\mathbf{3}}_c}[\bar{Q}_2\bar{Q}_4]_{\mathbf{3}_c}\right]_{\mathbf{1}}$ is absolutely dominant in the excited states because of the strong Coulomb attraction within the $[Q_1Q_2]_{\bar{\mathbf{3}}_c}$ and $[\bar{Q}_2\bar{Q}_4]_{\mathbf{3}_c}$. The $J/\Psi$-pair resonances recently observed by LHCb are difficult to be accommodated in the CMIM. The broad structure ranging from 6.2 to 6.8 GeV can be described as the ground tetraquark state $[cc][\bar{c}\bar{c}]$ in the various dynamical models. The narrow structure $X(6900)$ can be identified as the excited state $[cc][\bar{c}\bar{c}]$ with $L=1$ ($L=2$) in the CQM (MCFTM).