Towards diagnostic biotic indices for river macroinvertebrates

Abstract

The construction of biotic indices that use macroinvertebratesto assess pollution and other anthropogenic disturbances ofrivers and streams often requires that each taxon be assigned anumber indicating its level of sensitivity. A problem inconstructing such indices is that individual taxa may varyquite widely in sensivity, depending on the nature of theparticular disturbance. One possible means of overcoming thisproblem is to construct a suite of indices, each assembledusing sensitivity numbers targeted to a particular impact. In order to test this idea, we sampled macroinvertebrates fromrivers in south-eastern Australia subjected to three differenttypes of anthropogenic disturbance: operation of large dams,discharge of effluent from municipal sewage treatment plants,and contamination by metals originating from historical mining.Using macroinvertebrate data from sampling sites with varyinglevels of exposure to disturbance, we developed sensitivitynumbers for macroinvertebrate families for individual riversand combinations of rivers with the same disturbance type. Sensitivity numbers calculated for individual families differedsignificantly according to disturbance type in several cases.Gastropod molluscs (family Thiaridae) were tolerant of dameffects but sensitive to sewage and metals, whereascoenagrionid damselfly nymphs, elmid beetles and ostracods weremost tolerant of sewage. Corydalid alderfly larvae,leptophlebiid mayfly nymphs, lestid damselfly nymphs,libellulid dragonfly nymphs and scirtid beetle larvae weremost tolerant of metals. Indices constructed using sensitivitynumbers for a particular disturbance were generally mostresponsive to that disturbance, but there was considerablegenerality in responses as well as substantial variabilitybetween different rivers with the same disturbance type. Inparticular, macroinvertebrate communities at sites downstreamof dams responded quite variably, probably because ofsubstantial differences in release regimes. We conclude thatthe approach has merit but requires considerable furtherdevelopment and testing, as well as consideration of the levelsof specificity and diagnostic strength that are appropriate orachievable.