Towards developing a model of adaptive acoustic comfort in the built environment: A thematic analysis from an expert focus group

Abstract

The adaptive capacities of building occupants have so far been primarily investigated in relation to the thermal climate through the adaptive thermal comfort model. However, the concept of adaptation extends beyond thermal conditions and is relevant to other sensory modalities, such as acoustics. This is significant for both human health and well-being, as well as environmental considerations. The latter aspect is linked to potential variations in acoustic sensitivities between naturally ventilated and mechanically ventilated buildings, which, if identified and acknowledged, could lead to a greater applicability of passive ventilation strategies through tailored acoustic criteria. Drawing from thematic analysis of discussions held in a focus group comprising 8 experts in acoustics, soundscape, and adaptive thermal comfort, this study aims to 1) delineate the underlying assumptions of acoustic adaptation in built environments, and 2) establish a research agenda towards developing a framework for adaptive acoustic comfort. The identified themes include: the definition of adaptive acoustic comfort, potentially contributing acoustic and non-acoustic factors, differences and similarities with the adaptive thermal comfort model, and the methodology for collecting data. In terms of results, 1) adaptive acoustic comfort would be based on potential modifying effects of recent past acoustic exposure and other environmental factors (including multi-domain effects), contextual, and personal factors on people's acoustic expectations and preferences. 2) To test this concept, the very first step will have to be the construction of a comprehensive global acoustic comfort database.