To make a silk purse: The contract between reviewers/editors and authors

Abstract

As professionals we are sometimes asked to examine a report, a letter. … A lucky few have even been tapped to review and edit a manuscript for Geophysics. Those tempted to think that this requires simple scanning should think again. This is a journal, an archival record; to get a manuscript ready for publication is the equivalent of cutting and polishing a gem … or refinishing an old masterpiece … or working with precious woods. … It is all about eliminating imperfections while enhancing natural attributes without altering the nature and essence of the piece.