Abstract
BackgroundLong-term behavioral and health risk factors constitute a primary focus of research on the etiology of chronic diseases. Yet, identifying critical time-windows during which risk factors have the strongest impact on disease risk is challenging. To assess the trajectory of association of an exposure history with an outcome, the weighted cumulative exposure index (WCIE) has been proposed, with weights reflecting the relative importance of exposures at different times. However, WCIE is restricted to a complete observed error-free exposure whereas exposures are often measured with intermittent missingness and error. Moreover, it rarely explores exposure history that is very distant from the outcome as usually sought in life-course epidemiology.MethodsWe extend the WCIE methodology to (i) exposures that are intermittently measured with error, and (ii) contexts where the exposure time-window precedes the outcome time-window using a landmark approach. First, the individual exposure history up to the landmark time is estimated using a mixed model that handles missing data and error in exposure measurement, and the predicted complete error-free exposure history is derived. Then the WCIE methodology is applied to assess the trajectory of association between the predicted exposure history and the health outcome collected after the landmark time. In our context, the health outcome is a longitudinal marker analyzed using a mixed model.ResultsA simulation study first demonstrates the correct inference obtained with this approach. Then, applied to the Nurses’ Health Study (19,415 women) to investigate the association between body mass index history (collected from midlife) and subsequent cognitive decline (evaluated after age 70), the method identified two major critical windows of association: long before the first cognitive evaluation (roughly 24 to 12 years), higher levels of BMI were associated with poorer cognition. In contrast, adjusted for the whole history, higher levels of BMI became associated with better cognition in the last years prior to the first cognitive interview, thus reflecting reverse causation (changes in exposure due to underlying disease).ConclusionsThis approach, easy to implement, provides a flexible tool for studying complex dynamic relationships and identifying critical time windows while accounting for exposure measurement errors.
Highlights
Long-term behavioral and health risk factors constitute a primary focus of research on the etiology of chronic diseases
Application to body mass index history starting at mid-life and subsequent cognitive trajectories after age 70 To emphasize the utility of our methodology, we investigated in a prospective cohort study the relationship of Body mass index (BMI) history collected since mid-life with subsequent cognitive function and cognitive decline in older ages, where prior data indicate changing relations over time, with the possibility of reverse causation at older age [3,4,5]
The overall mean association of BMI history over the whole 24 year period of exposure was significant with a negative relation to cognition for both the initial level (-0.0013 [95% CI: -0.0014;-0.0012]) and the annual slope of decline in Telephone Interview for Cognitive Status (TICS) (-0.00016 [95% CI:-0.00019;-0.00015])
Summary
Long-term behavioral and health risk factors constitute a primary focus of research on the etiology of chronic diseases. Applied to the Nurses’ Health Study (19,415 women) to investigate the association between body mass index history (collected from midlife) and subsequent cognitive decline (evaluated after age 70), the method identified two major critical windows of association: long before the first cognitive evaluation (roughly 24 to 12 years), higher levels of BMI were associated with poorer cognition. Chronic diseases often result from a long and accumulating pathological process that evolves over years before diagnosis [1] In such context, the exposure time-windows close to the clinical event may be less meaningful in terms of etiology and, importantly, may be obscured by reverse causality (which occurs when behaviors or exposures change as the disease progresses in infra-clinic stages). The only valuable approach to evaluate causal associations linking cumulative unhealthy body weight to cognitive aging might be to estimate the relationship between the entire history of exposure that precedes and begins well upstream of the period at risk of the event
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a callDisclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.
